#19BOS : Biennale of Sydney responds to critics …


Above : 23yo asylum seeker Reza Berati, killed on Manus Island.

The Biennale of Sydney has issued the following statement in response to an open letter from concerned artists:

Firstly, let us say that we truly empathise with the artists in this situation.

Like them, we are inadvertently caught somewhere between ideology and principle. Both parties are ‘collateral damage’ in a complex argument. Neither wants to see human suffering.

Artists must make a decision according to their own understanding and beliefs. We respect their right to do so.

While being mindful of these valid concerns, it is this Board’s duty to act in the interests of the Biennale and all its stakeholders – our audiences, government partners, staff, benefactors and sponsors, along with all Biennale artists and the broader arts sector.

On the one hand, there are assertions and allegations that are open to debate. On the other, we have a long-term history of selfless philanthropy, which has been the foundation of an event that has served the arts and wider community for the past 40 years.

The Biennale’s ability to effectively contribute to the cessation of bi-partisan government policy is far from black and white. The only certainty is that without our Founding Partner, the Biennale will no longer exist.

Consequently, we unanimously believe that our loyalty to the Belgiorno-Nettis family – and the hundreds of thousands of people who benefit from the Biennale – must override claims over which there is ambiguity.

While we unequivocally state our support and gratitude for our sponsor’s continued patronage, we also extend an invitation to the Working Group to engage with us in dialogue with the purpose of finding an acceptable accommodation.

The Biennale has long been a platform for artists to air their sometimes challenging but important views unfettered and we would like to explore this avenue of expression, rather than see the demise of an important community asset.

…

After the Kapp Putsch of 1920 (an attempt by the radical right to violently overthrow the new Weimar Republic) clashes occurred between the army and workers in Dresden. A bullet went through the window of the Zwinger Gallery and damaged a Rubens painting. Incensed by the incident, Kokoschka – then art professor at the Dresden Academy – financed an appeal which appeared in local newspapers and as wallposters, urging the two sides to settle their scores well away from cultural treasures. Kokoschka’s elevation of art above political struggle outraged Grosz and Heartfield (political art activists) who replied with a furious polemic ‘Der Kunstlump’ (The Artist As Scab) ridiculing the idea that art could be considered more important than lives of workers. They welcomed the fact that bullets had penetrated galleries, palaces and a Rubens, rather than the homes of the poor.”

~ Photomontage: A Political Weapon, David Evans & Sylvia Gohl, Gordon Fraser, 1986

Posted in Art, State / Politics, That's Capitalism! | Tagged , , , , | 3 Comments

#19BOS update w BONUS! #fuckyeahandrewbolt

From the Department of #FUCKYEAHANDREWBOLT:

I’ve been hoping and praying that someone sensible would step in and sort out the mess surrounding the Sydney Biennale and no sooner had I written —

— than BINGO!

As a result, I have now become a WINNER!

Otherwise:

• Reportedly, six more artists — Sara van der Heide, Henna-Riikka Halonen, Ane Hjort Guttu, Hadley+Maxwell, Shannon Te Ao and Yael Bartana — have signed on to the Open letter from artists to the Board of Directors of the Biennale of Sydney, bringing the total number of engaged artists to 34 (over 1/3 of all artists exhibiting). The Board is meeting tonight to discuss the letter and to formulate a more formal response to the boycott than the following jerk of the knee:

• The Open Letter has also generated some virtual ink in Biennale of Sydney: artists send protest letter over detention centre links (Nicole Hasham, The Sydney Morning Herald, February 19, 2014) and Biennale artists want Transfield out (Deborah Stone, ArtsHub, February 19, 2014); four of the artists — Hester, Gray, de Vietri and Sofo — are interviewed about the boycott, the Biennale and Transfield in Crikey’s Daily Review here.

• In other news, ARTINFOAustralia ‏– the same mob that first responded to the boycott by tweeting that “The Biennale is an incredible event and a great asset to Sydney and Australia. End of story.” — has now published an article on the subject (Artists Protest Over Biennale of Sydney’s Links with Detention Centres, Nicholas Forrest, February 19, 2014), while the story has also been written about by Fairfax (The ethical minefield of arts sponsorship, Fiona Gruber, February 19, 2014) and Murdoch (Artists demand Biennale of Sydney severs ties with company linked to asylum seeker detention centres, Elizabeth Fortescue, February 19, 2014).

• An online petition has been launched while Facebook is blocking links to a discussion on boycott tactics on the xborderoperationalmatters blog.

• I’m unaware of the precise level of financial support Transfield provides for #19BOS but an article in the Financial Times (Wealth of talents, Cristina Ruiz, September 7, 2012) states that “[t]he execution and installation of [a] work, one of hundreds in five venues across the city as part of the 18th edition of the Sydney Biennale, were paid for by a private foundation set up by local philanthropists Luca Belgiorno-Nettis and his wife Anita, just two of the many wealthy individuals who have contributed to the costs of the exhibition. This private support, which accounts for 21 per cent of the Sydney Biennale’s A$10.7m ($11m) budget, has given the curators the freedom to choose artists whose work may be difficult to sell.”

• Finally, Helen Razer has composed a slightly daft piece titled Sydney Biennale: artists divide over dirty money (February 20, 2014). And while there’s probably little point in engaging with it — more productive discussions on strategy + tactics are taking place elsewhere — it may be worth making a few notes. First, rendering political positions suspect through invoking the notion of ‘purity’ is a familiar one to anarchists; secondly, abstracting the call for a boycott from its location within a broader critique of the regime of mandatory detention tends to render invisible the wider struggle from within which the campaign emerged (and for which it forms one of many parts).

See also : #19BOS Action: Biennale of Sydney and Transfield [5.30pm, Monday, February 24, Melbourne] + Collated links for 19th Biennale of Sydney Boycott.

Posted in Art, State / Politics, That's Capitalism! | Tagged , , , , , , | 2 Comments

Open letter from artists to the Board of Directors of the Biennale of Sydney [#19BOS]

19 February 2014

To the Board of Directors of the Biennale of Sydney,

We are a group of artists ­— Gabrielle de Vietri, Bianca Hester, Charlie Sofo, Nathan Gray, Deborah Kelly, Matt Hinkley, Benjamin Armstrong, Libia Castro, Ólafur Ólafsson, Sasha Huber, Sonia Leber, David Chesworth, Daniel McKewen, Angelica Mesiti, Ahmet Öğüt, Meriç Algün Ringborg, Joseph Griffiths, Sol Archer, Tamas Kaszas, Krisztina Erdei, Nathan Coley, Corin Sworn, Ross Manning, Martin Boyce, Callum Morton, Emily Roysdon, Søren Thilo Funder, Mikhail Karikis ­— all participants in the 19th Biennale of Sydney.

We are writing to you about our concerns with the Biennale’s sponsorship arrangement with Transfield.[1]

We would like to begin with an affirmation and recognition of the Biennale staff, other sponsors and donors, and our fellow artists. We maintain the utmost respect for Juliana Engberg’s artistic vision and acknowledge the support and energy that the Biennale staff have put into the creation of our projects and this exhibition. We acknowledge that this issue places the Biennale team in a difficult situation.

However, we want to emphasise that this issue has presented us with an opportunity to become aware of, and to acknowledge, responsibility for our own participation in a chain of connections that links to human suffering; in this case, that is caused by Australia’s policy of mandatory detention.

We trust that you understand the implications of Transfield’s recent move to secure new contracts to take over garrison and welfare services in Australia’s offshore immigration detention centres on Manus Island and in Nauru. We have attached for your information, a document that outlines our understanding of the links between the Biennale, Transfield and Australia’s asylum seeker policy.

We appeal to you to work alongside us to send a message to Transfield, and in turn the Australian Government and the public: that we will not accept the mandatory detention of asylum seekers, because it is ethically indefensible and in breach of human rights; and that, as a network of artists, arts workers and a leading cultural organisation, we do not want to be associated with these practices.

Our current circumstances are complex: public institutions are increasingly reliant on private finance, and less on public funding, and this can create ongoing difficulties. We are aware of these complexities and do not believe that there is one easy answer to the larger situation.

However, in this particular case, we regard our role in the Biennale, under the current sponsorship arrangements, as adding value to the Transfield brand. Participation is an active endorsement, providing cultural capital for Transfield.

In light of all this, we ask the Board: what will you do? We urge you to act in the interests of asylum seekers. As part of this we request the Biennale withdraw from the current sponsorship arrangements with Transfield and seek to develop new ones. This will set an important precedent for Australian and international arts institutions, compelling them to exercise a greater degree of ethical awareness and transparency regarding their funding sources. We are asking you, respectfully, to respond with urgency.

Our interests as artists don’t merely concern our individual moral positions. We are concerned too with the ways cultural institutions deal with urgent social responsibilities. We expect the Biennale to acknowledge the voice of its audience and the artist community that is calling on the institution to act powerfully and immediately for justice by cutting its ties with Transfield.

We believe that artists and art­workers can — and should — create an environment that empowers individuals and groups to act on conscience, opening up other pathways to develop more sustainable, and in turn sustaining, forms of cultural production.

We want to extend this discussion to a range of people and organisations, in order to bring to light the various forces shaping our current situation, and to work towards imagining other possibilities into being. In our current political circumstances we believe this to be one of the most crucial challenges that we are compelled to engage with, and we invite you into this process of engagement.

We look forward to hearing your response and given the urgency of this issue, hope that we can receive it by the end of this week.

Thank you for your consideration.

Sincerely,

Gabrielle de Vietri, Bianca Hester, Charlie Sofo, Nathan Gray, Deborah Kelly, Matt Hinkley, Benjamin Armstrong, Libia Castro, Ólafur Ólafsson, Sasha Huber, Sonia Leber, David Chesworth, Daniel McKewen, Angelica Mesiti, Ahmet Öğüt, Meriç Algün Ringborg, Joseph Griffiths, Sol Archer, Tamas Kaszas, Krisztina Erdei, Nathan Coley, Corin Sworn, Ross Manning, Martin Boyce, Callum Morton, Emily Roysdon, Søren Thilo Funder, Mikhail Karikis

NOTES 1. Please note that in this document we use the name Transfield to refer to three branches of the Transfield brand: Transfield Holdings, Services and Foundation.

Posted in Art, State / Politics, That's Capitalism! | Tagged , , , | 5 Comments

Rally and march v Napthine’s Silencing Act: 10am, Tuesday, February 18, 2014

Yeah so there’s a rally (at Trades Hall) and march (to Parliament) tomorrow to protest Premier Napthine’s new laws (Summary Offences and Sentencing Amendment Bill 2013 plus) intended to repress community and union pickets and make the public understand they’re only getting in the way and should stay at home …

Silly buggers.

See : Australian state government bolsters “move-on” police powers, Daniel Saul, wsws.org, February 17, 2014 | New police powers to deal with pickets in Victoria, Herbert Smith Freehills, December 19, 2013.

Posted in State / Politics | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

“Give me the money Jew or else I will get you” (antifa notes, feb 16, 2014)

Some brief notes.

A bloke by the name of Neil Luke Erikson “has avoided jail for abusing a Melbourne rabbi in a series of racially-motivated phone calls he tried to explain as a prank”.

Hurr hurr.

Erikson has form, counter-protesting the Wilders demonstration in Somerton in February last year …

… and also attending an anti-Muslim rally outside the State Library in September, 2012.

In both cases, Erikson was working with members of Melbourne-based neo-Nazi groupuscule Nationalist Alternative.

See also : Who’s Keeping An Eye on Aussie Neo-Nazis?, New Matilda, January 22, 2014.

Posted in Anti-fascism | Tagged , , , | 3 Comments

Boycott the 19th Biennale of Sydney [#19bos]

[Update (February 19) : The boycott campaign now has a website and Facebook page.]

A few weeks ago Matt Kiem wrote ‘An art educator’s open letter to colleagues about detention profits and the Sydney Biennale’ (Crossborder Operational Matters, February 4, 2014). It outlines the case for artists and the public to boycott the event on the basis of its sponsorship by Transfield, an Australian-based corporation which profits from the asylum seeker industry.

The xborderoperationalmatters blog is an excellent resource for matters relating to the policing of Australian borders; RISE is a grassroots initiative “and the first refugee and asylum seeker welfare and advocacy organisation in Australia to be run by refugees, asylum seekers, and ex-detainees; as such, we view those who seek assistance from RISE as members and participants, not “clients”.”

Otherwise, #19BOS is a tumblr which compiles a contact list for artists appearing at the Biennale. In Sydney on Monday, February 17 at 6.30pm at Elwyn Lynn Conference Room, College of Fine Art, Oxford Street, there’ll be an “open discussion on how artists and activists can protest against Transfield’s sponsorship of the 2014 Sydney Biennale”.

The following video has been created in support of the boycott:

transfield and the sydney biennale from Beyond Borders on Vimeo.

The following articles discuss the boycott:

• Sydney Biennale faces Transfield boycott threat, Ben Eltham, ArtsHub, February 7, 2014
• The 19th Biennale of Sydney & their partner Transfield, Excerpt Magazine, February 7, 2014
• Supporting the call to Boycott the 19th Biennale of Sydney (2014), Van Thanh Rudd, February 8, 2014
• Why I Will Be Boycotting the 2014 Sydney Biennale- Protest Refugee Detention Centre Profiteering in Corporate Sponsorship, Ruth Skilbeck, February 8, 2014
• Should artists boycott the Sydney Biennale over Transfield links?, Matt Kiem, The Conversation, February 12, 2014
• Sydney Biennale and a question of corporate sponsorship, Antony Lowenstein, The Guardian, February 12, 2014
• Beyond Borders Report – Why to boycott Transfield & the Biennale, beyond borders collective melbourne, February 13, 2014
• Boycott The Sydney Biennale, Kevin Loo, literatico, February 14, 2014

• Collated links for 19th Biennale of Sydney Boycott

See also : ‘The Work of Art and the Problem of Politics in Dada Berlin’, Brigid Doherty, October, No.105, Summer 2003.

After the Kapp Putsch of 1920 (an attempt by the radical right to violently overthrow the new Weimar Republic) clashes occurred between the army and workers in Dresden. A bullet went through the window of the Zwinger Gallery and damaged a Rubens painting. Incensed by the incident, Kokoschka – then art professor at the Dresden Academy – financed an appeal which appeared in local newspapers and as wallposters, urging the two sides to settle their scores well away from cultural treasures. Kokoschka’s elevation of art above political struggle outraged Grosz and Heartfield (political art activists) who replied with a furious polemic ‘Der Kunstlump’ (The Artist As Scab) ridiculing the idea that art could be considered more important than lives of workers. They welcomed the fact that bullets had penetrated galleries, palaces and a Rubens, rather than the homes of the poor.”

~ Photomontage: A Political Weapon, David Evans & Sylvia Gohl, Gordon Fraser, 1986

Posted in Art, Broken Windows, Death, Media, State / Politics, That's Capitalism! | Tagged , , , , , , | 5 Comments

A rose … [on anarchy and summit protest and stuff | overland]

I wrote some stuff for overland zine about the phony ‘Black Rose Syndicat’, black blocs and teh anarchy. You can find it here. It was inspired by Clive Williams’ rather poor article in The Canberra Times, which you can read there.

Posted in !nataS, Anarchism, Broken Windows, History, Media, State / Politics, That's Capitalism!, War on Terror | 3 Comments

The WikiLeaks Party’s administrative error [Crikey]

The ‘highly emotional and volatile’ world of the WikiLeaks Party
Bernard Keane
Crikey
February 7, 2014

The aftermath of the WikiLeaks Party’s electoral debut reached a new and unexpected level of farce today when the party released its much-heralded “independent review” of the circumstances around its allocation of preferences in the lead-up to the September federal election.

The party announced the review in August after the uproar over its decision to allocate preferences to the Nationals ahead of the Greens in Western Australia and to direct preferences to the Shooters and Fishers Party and the far-Right Australia First Party ahead of the Greens in New South Wales. The party subsequently blamed an “administrative error” for the debacle, which prompted a spate of resignations from key figures, including the party’s No. 2 Senate candidate in Victoria, Dr Leslie Cannold.

Today, the “review” has finally been released, via email to members. It was conducted by Stuart Bell of Bell Campbell Auditing, a WikiLeaks Party member approached by John Shipton, Julian Assange’s father, to conduct the audit. The review is six pages long, including the cover page and an attachment. In it, Bell complains that his conduct of the review was “limited” by his “inability or access to all relevant information and WLP personnel, especially where there has been a severe fall-out over the 2013 preferencing issues in NSW and WA”.

Bell had not been able to interview anyone except for Shipton, but says he took written submissions or phone calls from other key figures like Greg Barns. Bell also laments “limited or no access to WLP official transcripts, minutes of National Council meetings and official emails/correspondence”, which forced him to accept the word of those he interviewed. However, Bell rejected the “administrative error” claim by the party:

“It cannot be shown that it was an ‘administrative error’, based on the electronic and verbal hyper-activity by the National Council members … It was a combination of human errors caused by a highly emotional and volatile atmosphere, where a number of key WLP members were instrumental in causing confusion, not from malicious intent but due to a lack of defined responsibilities.”

Bell goes on to recommend that the party make its preference allocation decisions earlier and that someone formally be given the job of overseeing the allocation process. Party secretary Matt Watt said in the email accompanying the review this morning:

“[T]he circumstances of the 2013 Federal Election Group Voting Tickets have triggered a need to re-examine what the party does and determine how it can improve further. A promise to learn — a commitment to act: The WikiLeaks Party will analyse and evaluate the findings from the internal review and ensure that improvements are made.”

At three-and-a-half pages of actual text, evaluation shouldn’t take too long.

[See also : WikiLeaks Party : R U Syrias?, January 13, 2014.]

Posted in State / Politics | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment

antifa notes (february 4, 2014)

A few notes.

First, I published an article in New Matilda last week about the Australian Defence League.

Secondly, one of the groupuscules I referred to in the article, the Party for Freedom, was to have held a public meeting at Redfern Town Hall on Thursday, February 6, to discuss how awful Africans are. The Party has now transferred the venue to Humanist House in Chippendale.

Or maybe not.

According to Party Chairman Nicholas Hunter-Folkes — the man who believes Third World peoples, including Africans, ought to be sterilised so as to keep them from reproducing — leftists have forced management at the House to cancel the meeting. In addition, the Party’s website was allegedly subject to a DDOS attack on the weekend.

Further details of the non-meeting may be obtained from either Nick on 0417-679 972 or [email protected] and/or Andy on 0434-559485 or [email protected].

(Note that Humanist House was the subject of an unsuccessful coup attempt by neo-Nazis in 2010.)

Finally, four men were found guilty last week in a Perth court for distributing racist stickers promoting Combat 18 — stickers also being distributed by boneheads in Melbourne’s northern suburbs. One of the men convicted, Jacob Marshall Hort, was previously responsible for administering a Combat 18 website (terrormachine.net) and played in the band ‘Indigenous Hate’. In July 2010, Hort was convicted of criminal damage and discharging a firearm stemming from an incident in which several shots were fired at the Queens Park Suleymaniye Mosque, causing $15,000 damage.

Note that Hort & Co have been denounced by ‘Blood & Honour Australia’ (that faction aligned with the Hammerskins) as liars and traitors; his (former?) C18 comrade, Bradley Trappitt, has since been welcomed into the New Right/’national anarchist’ camp by its leader Welf Herfurth. What this means for relations between B&H/C18, B&H/SCHS, the New Right and Volksfront is unclear at this stage.

Four men fined over racial hate stickers
Kalamunda Reporter
January 28, 2014

A HIGH Wycombe man was among four men fined a total of $8200 in Armadale Magistrates Court for placing racially motivated stickers across a number of Perth suburbs, including Midland and Glen Forrest.

Jacob Marshall Hort (27) and three other men, aged in their 20s and 30s, faced a total of 28 charges of criminal damage for posting the stickers on property, including shopping centres, rubbish bins, an ATM and car parking signs.

The WA police State security investigation group began an investigation into the group after a front-page report published in the Hills Gazette’s sister paper Midland-Kalamunda Reporter in February of last year.

The report detailed the stickers, which showed a swastika and a man clad in a balaclava with his arm in a nazi salute, together with website details, an email address and contact mobile phone number, had been placed on a City of Swan carpark sign, on The Avenue, asking residents to “support your local skinheads”.

The group was charged in August and September after an extensive police investigation.

The court heard five men had placed stickers in Cannington, Maddington, Gosnells, Thornlie and Seville Grove.

Desmond Liddington (29), of Busselton, Jordan Richard Dyer (29), of Bunbury, and Toby Adam Middlecoat (39), of Carlisle, were also convicted, along with Hort.

A Westminster man (36) failed to appear in court and an arrest warrant has been issued.

PS. Oh yeah. A handful of members of the Australia First Party attempted to disrupt a march on Invasion Day in Brisbane.

Posted in Anti-fascism | Tagged , , , , , , | 4 Comments

#FreeJoel [international appeal for solidarity with swedish antifa]

::: International call for solidarity! :::

We, anti-fascists of Stockholm, call upon the international left-wing movement to show solidarity and support to one of our imprisoned comrades. He is in jail for defending a local community-organized anti-racist demonstration in the Kärrtorp area of Stockholm against a brutal nazi-attack on the 15th of December. Locals of all sorts, including parents with their children, elderly and youth, gathered in their neighbourhood to show strength against a nazi organisation that had been attacking local anti-racists and spreading nazi propaganda in schools in the area. They gathered in a peaceful protest when they were attacked by the most militant nazi group in Sweden with knives, sticks and glass bottles. Anti-fascists at the scene defended the local families from the attack and were injured themselves. One of the anti-fascists got arrested by the police a few days later although the anti-fascists did nothing but defend themselves.

A week later, on the 22nd of December, the largest manifestation in modern history in Sweden against racism and nazism took place in the same area. Around 20.000 people gathered with a clear message: Nazis are not welcome in our society!

Although the left-wing people of Stockholm showed strength we need your solidarity, your solidarity actions and your letters to our imprisoned comrade!

:::

For moar infos pls see the Free Joel facebook page.

Posted in Anti-fascism, Media | Tagged , , , | Leave a comment